Compared by formula
Compared by formula.
Smashed thin for maximum crust or kept thick for maximum juice β the same ground beef, two different arguments.
Start here
Nothing picked yet, so this is simply the most-rated version of the 65 we compared. Pick a style above and the answer changes.
from onceuponachef.com
Every dot is one published recipe, placed by its measured formula. The ring is your pick β click any other dot to see that version.
Read from 349 reviews across all 65 recipes. The counts are how many cooks report it β including where they disagree.
Adding an egg (often with panko or oatmeal) to a lean turkey or veggie patty mix that seems dry is associated with a juicier result.
Buttering (or oiling) the bread directly and griddling it butter-side-down produces a crisper crust than buttering only the pan or brushing butter on after cooking.
Cooking directly on a stovetop griddle or grill produces a deeper sear crust than baking in the oven or a foil-lined toaster oven.
Actively toasting or broiling the bread before assembling the sandwich produces a crisper result than relying on a single griddle pass, or on crisping only after assembly, especially with a wet filling like marinara.
A fattier ground turkey blend (90/10) is more prone to falling apart on the griddle than a very lean (99% fat-free) blend, which reviewers reported holding together reliably.
Each one has its own breakdown: formula, cost, time, and how it ranks.