Compared by formula

Red Beans and Rice

Compared by formula.

Beans simmered until some of them break down into the pot liquor, served over rice that has to stay separate.

31recipes
24sites
1kcook ratings
187reviews read
15proven levers
Cake Cafe Faubourg Marigny New Orleans - Red Beans and Rice Cup
Infrogmation of New Orleans · CC BY 2.0
Not enough data to rank this one yet

21 of 31 red beans and rice recipes rank on the formula map. The other 10 never state a weighable amount of rice, so they appear unranked.

What kind do you like?

Pick one and the answer appears — everything else is optional

Start here

The one most cooks reach for

Nothing picked yet, so this is simply the most-rated version of the 31 we compared. Pick a style above and the answer changes.

Tonight:
Red Beans and Rice
Infrogmation of New Orleans · CC BY 2.0 · illustrates the dish, not this recipe
protein addliquidaromaticsvegetables and beansfatsaltacidprotein add · liquid · aromatics · vegetables and beans · fat · salt · acid

Instant Pot Red Beans and Rice

from tastesbetterfromscratch.com

★★★★★ 4.87 (299)
no mixerbeginner
hands-on10m
waiting1.4 hr
makes6
each$1.72
kcal639
levelbeginner

Where your pick sits among all 31

Every dot is one published recipe, placed by its measured formula. The ring is your pick — click any other dot to see that version.

0% 356% 711% 0%173%346%519%692% less liquid → more liquid light meat → smoked-meat-loaded your pick Instant Pot Red Beans and Rice — tastesbetterfromscratch.com Slow Cooker Red Beans and Rice — eatingonadime.com Louisiana Style Red Beans and Rice with Sausage — budgetbytes.com Vegan Red Beans and Rice — budgetbytes.com Quickie Red Beans and Rice — budgetbytes.com Red Beans and Rice — chilipeppermadness.com Slow Cooker Red Beans and Rice with Chicken Sausage — melskitchencafe.com Red Beans and Rice — thecountrycook.net Louisiana Red Beans and Rice — downshiftology.com Red Beans & Rice Casserole — plainchicken.com Red Beans and Rice — dinneratthezoo.com Crock Pot Red Beans and Rice — gimmesomeoven.com Red Beans and Rice — smalltownwoman.com Red Beans and Rice — cafedelites.com One-Pot Red Beans and Rice — southernbite.com Red Beans and Rice (Louisiana-Style Recipe) — insanelygoodrecipes.com One Pot Red Beans and Rice — iowagirleats.com Red Beans and Rice — cookingclassy.com Southern Style Red Beans and Rice — thestayathomechef.com Crock Pot Red Beans and Rice — iowagirleats.com Red Beans and Rice — therecipecritic.com Jamaican Red Beans and Rice — skinnytaste.com Red Beans And Rice — chelseasmessyapron.com Red Beans and Rice — eatingonadime.com Red Beans and Rice — culinaryhill.com Red Beans and Rice — jocooks.com Red Beans and Rice — spicysouthernkitchen.com Cajun Red Beans and Rice — amandascookin.com What to Serve with Red Beans and Rice (12 Cajun Sides) — insanelygoodrecipes.com Red Beans and Rice — gimmesomeoven.com Slow Cooker Red Beans and Rice — plainchicken.com

What cooks found out

Read from 187 reviews across all 31 recipes. The counts are how many cooks report it — including where they disagree.

The dish's saltiness is driven mainly by the sodium content of the broth, soy sauce, or seasoning blend used rather than by added table salt - swapping in low-sodium broth, low-sodium soy sauce, or a milder seasoning blend measurably reduces saltiness, while using regular full-sodium versions or naturally salty add-ins (andouille, kielbasa, oyster sauce) increases it.

8 cooks report this · 1 report the opposite

Alternative whole grains - quinoa, farro, barley, or steel-cut oats - can successfully replace the rice called for in these dishes while keeping a similar hearty/creamy texture, though steel-cut oats specifically can come out bland and overpowering for some tasters.

6 cooks report this · 1 report the opposite

Cooking the rice ahead of time and letting it cool (whether overnight or just same-day) before using it produces noticeably more distinct, separate grains than using freshly hot-cooked rice, especially in fried-rice-style dishes.

backed by 13 cooks · benefit scales with chill time - a full day/overnight tends to outperform only a brief ~30 minute chill

Adding extra liquid (broth or water) beyond the recipe's stated amount increases the dish's moistness, and is commonly needed when the rice is still firm/dry at the end of the normal cook time - but overshooting the extra liquid can push the result to soggy or watery.

backed by 9 cooks

Using too little liquid relative to the amount of rice/grain in this dish causes the bottom to scorch or burn (frequently triggering the Instant Pot's burn warning) before the rice finishes cooking.

backed by 6 cooks · most common when a recipe is doubled without proportionally increasing liquid, or in electric pressure cookers/thin-bottomed pots

Frozen vegetables can be substituted for fresh vegetables in this dish family without noticeably hurting the final result.

backed by 6 cooks

All 31 red beans and rice recipes we measured

Each one has its own breakdown: formula, cost, time, and how it ranks.

Instant Pot Red Beans and Rice · 4.87★
Louisiana Style Red Beans and Rice with Sausage · 4.52★
Vegan Red Beans and Rice · 4.77★
Slow Cooker Red Beans and Rice · 4.98★
Quickie Red Beans and Rice · 4.89★
Slow Cooker Red Beans and Rice with Chicken Sausage · 4.62★
Red Beans and Rice · 4.93★
Red Beans and Rice · 5.0★
Crock Pot Red Beans and Rice · 4.35★
Louisiana Red Beans and Rice · 5.0★
Red Beans & Rice Casserole · 5.0★
Red Beans and Rice · 5.0★
Red Beans and Rice · 5.0★
Red Beans and Rice · 5.0★
One-Pot Red Beans and Rice · 5.0★
Red Beans and Rice (Louisiana-Style Recipe) · 4.6★
One Pot Red Beans and Rice · 4.78★
Southern Style Red Beans and Rice · 4.75★
Red Beans and Rice · 5.0★
Crock Pot Red Beans and Rice · 4.75★
Red Beans and Rice · 5.0★
Jamaican Red Beans and Rice · 5.0★
Red Beans And Rice · 5.0★
Red Beans and Rice · 5.0★
Red Beans and Rice · 5.0★
Red Beans and Rice · 5.0★
Red Beans and Rice · 5.0★
Cajun Red Beans and Rice · 5.0★
What to Serve with Red Beans and Rice (12 Cajun Sides) · 5.0★
Red Beans and Rice · 5.0★
Slow Cooker Red Beans and Rice · 5.0★