Compared by formula

Flour Tortillas

Compared by formula.

Lard or shortening, rested or not — the difference between a tortilla that rolls thin and one that fights back.

22recipes
18sites
1kcook ratings
113reviews read
15proven levers
Corn tortilla, medium flour tortilla, and large flour tortilla, stacked
Vigilantcosmicpenguin · CC BY 4.0

What kind do you like?

Pick one and the answer appears — everything else is optional

Start here

The one most cooks reach for

Nothing picked yet, so this is simply the most-rated version of the 22 we compared. Pick a style above and the answer changes.

Tonight:
Flour Tortillas
Vigilantcosmicpenguin · CC BY 4.0 · illustrates the dish, not this recipe
liquidfatsaltyeastflour proteinliquid · fat · salt · yeast · flour protein

Sourdough Flour Tortillas (made with discard or not)

from alexandracooks.com

★★★★★ 5 (219)
sourdough_starterno mixerno chillingkids can help
hands-on25m
waiting30 min
makes6
each$0.13
levelintermediate
Contains:dairygluten
Needs:sourdough_starter As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases

Where your pick sits among all 22

Every dot is one published recipe, placed by its measured formula. The ring is your pick — click any other dot to see that version.

48% 99% 150% 4%16%29%41%54% lean → lard-rich stiffer → slacker dough your pick Sourdough Flour Tortillas (made with discard or not) — alexandracooks.com Homemade Flour Tortillas — isabeleats.com Homemade Flour Tortilla — natashaskitchen.com Flour Tortillas — gimmesomeoven.com Cassava Flour Tortillas (Gluten-Free Tortillas) — downshiftology.com Easy Homemade Flour Tortillas — alexandracooks.com Homemade Flour Tortillas — cookingclassy.com Homemade Flour Tortillas — favfamilyrecipes.com Flour Tortillas — tastesbetterfromscratch.com Flour Tortillas v.2.0 (low fat) — budgetbytes.com Cassava Flour Tortillas (Grain-Free) — minimalistbaker.com Flour Tortillas — jocooks.com Homemade flour tortillas — simply-delicious-food.com Flour Tortillas — budgetbytes.com Homemade Flour Tortillas — browneyedbaker.com Homemade Flour Tortilla — eatingonadime.com Flour Tortillas — kingarthurbaking.com Keto-Friendly Flour Tortillas — kingarthurbaking.com Homemade Flour Tortillas — momontimeout.com Homemade Flour Tortillas — twopeasandtheirpod.com Flour Tortilla — sugarspunrun.com Gluten-Free Flour Tortillas — kingarthurbaking.com

What cooks found out

Read from 113 reviews across all 22 recipes. The counts are how many cooks report it.

Dough that strays from the recipe's flour-to-water ratio in either direction - extra flour worked in to rescue a wet dough, extra water added to loosen a stiff one, or a flour-type swap like a gluten-free blend - reliably tanks workability (scores of 1-3), while dough kept close to spec stays workable across pizza, bagels, pretzels, and bread.

backed by 11 cooks

A cold ferment stretched to 18-48 hours in the fridge consistently deepens flavour and improves rise, and often eases shaping, across pizza dough, focaccia, and no-knead bread.

backed by 10 cooks

For bagels and pretzels, full submersion and adequate contact time in the baking-soda (or lye) bath - especially with molasses or brown sugar added - drives the browning (char depth) and crackly crust that a skipped or shortchanged bath fails to produce.

backed by 7 cooks

Uncontrolled top-heat exposure - matching top and bottom heat, baking uncovered too long, pooling egg wash, or burn-prone toppings - tips char depth into scorched territory; tenting with foil or avoiding those toppings keeps browning controlled.

backed by 5 cooks

All 22 flour tortillas recipes we measured

Each one has its own breakdown: formula, cost, time, and how it ranks.

Sourdough Flour Tortillas (made with discard or not) · 5.0★
Homemade Flour Tortillas · 4.78★
Homemade Flour Tortilla · 5.0★
Cassava Flour Tortillas (Gluten-Free Tortillas) · 4.72★
Flour Tortillas · 4.91★
Easy Homemade Flour Tortillas · 5.0★
Cassava Flour Tortillas (Grain-Free) · 4.12★
Homemade Flour Tortillas · 5.0★
Flour Tortillas v.2.0 (low fat) · 4.41★
Flour Tortillas · 4.65★
Homemade Flour Tortillas · 5.0★
Flour Tortillas · 4.8★
Homemade flour tortillas · 4.6★
Flour Tortillas · 5.0★
Homemade Flour Tortillas · 4.88★
Keto-Friendly Flour Tortillas · 4.0★
Homemade Flour Tortilla · 5.0★
Flour Tortillas · 5.0★
Flour Tortilla · 4.5★
Homemade Flour Tortillas · 5.0★
Homemade Flour Tortillas · 5.0★
Gluten-Free Flour Tortillas · 4.0★